"The customer isn't always right, but their experience is always real." Lori was getting ready to teach that line in a holiday selling workshop the very next day, and it turned out to be the perfect summary of the retail story everyone was watching that week: Kelly Clarkson, a small Brooklyn shop, and a $15,000 singing and dancing mechanical bird named Molly. So Lori and Ellie did what any two people with strong opinions would do. They went through it play by play, and then asked what a flower shop should take from it.
What happened, as Lori and Ellie tell it
Ellie read the recap. Kelly Clarkson posted that she had driven all the way to Brooklyn to visit a shop she thought looked really rad, with a few things in mind to buy, and was "looked at as if I couldn't afford it" and told he could find her something comparable. She compared it to Julia Roberts in Pretty Woman. By the time of the recording, Ellie said, the post had been viewed 44 million times.
The next day the shop answered on Instagram. The item she wanted, it said, was a singing and dancing bird automaton named Molly that is permanently attached to the wall and not for sale. Clarkson replied with a photo of a price tag on the wall next to the bird: $15,000. From there the shop dug in, saying in a video interview that she had put them in danger, and adding a new joke price tag of $15 million.
Lori and Ellie are careful about what they don't know. The video that was released has no audio, and as Ellie says, we don't have both sides. What they could see: Clarkson in a yellow t-shirt, baseball cap, sweats and a backpack, shopping with her son. She politely put back everything she had in her hands and walked out. From what they understood, the person who waited on her was a co-owner.
Never decide what a customer can afford
Lori starts with what she calls customer service 101. Someone had a preconceived idea of how a person should look when they walk into that store and what they could spend. "When billionaires wear pajamas on an airplane, why would you ever make that assumption?" She is honest that the pressure is real from the shopper's side too. If she's headed one direction in her town, she goes in sweatpants and a cap. If she's headed to the nicer shopping area, she wouldn't dream of it. "That's my problem. That's not hers. No one should feel that way."
Ellie points to the specific miss: steering her from the $15,000 bird to a $2,000 one. That is an assumption standing in for a question. A shop owner has plenty of ways to find out what someone is looking for without guessing from an outfit.
Here is the flower shop version. A customer is admiring the $500 arrangement on display. If your reflex is "I can find you something less expensive," you may have just talked yourself out of a sale, and Ellie adds that maybe they wanted to spend $700. Lori's rule: "If someone's asking me about the $15,000 bird, I'm going to assume they're interested in the $15,000 bird until they tell me they're not." It's the way a luxury store hands you the bag you asked to see. If the customer says it's too much, that is when you bring out the $2,000 bird.
Ellie tried to give the owner some grace. Maybe a tourist broke something that morning, or someone took an hour of his time and bought nothing. Was it the wrong moment, or is this just how he is? Lori thinks the response afterward answers that.
If it really isn't for sale, show them you tried
Lori often teaches a story from Simon Sinek. He called an airline hoping for an upgrade and got a flat answer: sorry, you don't have that status. He hung up hating them. If the agent had said, "Let me see what I can do," and come back with, "I'm so sorry, I even asked my boss, I wish there were something else we could do," the outcome would be exactly the same and he would have felt completely different. In any service situation, the thing that matters most isn't the refund. It's whether the customer felt heard.
Ellie's version: it's communicating in a way that makes customers feel valued rather than rejected.
So suppose the bird truly wasn't for sale. Lori knows exactly what she'd say: "Oh, I know, isn't it so great? Here's the thing. This one I can't sell you, but come over here. Let me check the computer and see where I can find one. Maybe we can get one shipped to you." Ellie compares it to your display stands: people want to buy those all the time, but they're part of the display. Showing that you tried also protects you later. If a customer complains that you wouldn't sell it, you can honestly say you looked for a solution.
The response is where it went from awkward to viral
The second lesson is what happens after. Ellie says it looks like common sense in hindsight: acknowledge that the customer has feelings and felt a certain way. Something like, we're so sorry she felt that way, and we never want anyone to be treated as less than. What happened was a denial, a price tag photo that contradicted it, a claim of being put in danger and then the $15 million joke. As Ellie notes, it's hard to make the case that you're a small business in danger while joking about a $15 million bird. Lori's summary: "They just keep throwing themselves under the bus every single time."
Ellie sees a parallel between restaurants and floristry. If a guest says the steak isn't cooked right, a good restaurant doesn't argue, even if the kitchen got it right. They acknowledge the experience and fix it.
One bright spot: Lori has been watching flower shops and other small businesses on TikTok post "Dear Kelly, come to our store" videos, showing off what she could buy and tagging her. "That's how you do it."
One more story: the wedding venue and the $16,000 deposit
Lori brought a second controversy she found on TikTok and then read up on. As reported, a couple put down a $16,000 deposit at a Texas wedding venue for a November wedding, and then the groom died. The bride asked for her money back. According to the coverage Lori read, the venue said it was sorry for her loss, declined the refund, offered to move the booking to a future date, and then countersued for the balance of the contract.
Ellie's reaction to the venue's written reply was that it sounded like a robot wrote it without anyone thinking it through. Lori noted that other venue owners and planners have weighed in to say that with months of notice they can usually rebook the date and refund most of a deposit. Ellie could see keeping a small percentage. Finding no middle ground at all was what neither of them could understand. For Lori, it came down to one thing: the humanity of it all.
Lori ended on a happier note. That Saturday she walked into a new locally owned boutique in her sweatpants, and they offered her a piece of cake. As Ellie says, Kelly could wander into your store no matter where you are, so make sure your team is trained for it.
Key takeaways
- Never judge a customer's budget by what they're wearing. Assume they want what they asked about until they tell you otherwise.
- Ask questions before you redirect. Offering "something comparable" before they've mentioned price tells them what you think of them.
- If you can't say yes, show the effort: check the computer, offer to order one, look for a solution.
- When a complaint goes public, acknowledge how the customer felt before you defend yourself.
- The customer isn't always right, but their experience is always real, and it's the experience they'll tell people about.
- Train your team on all of this. You never know who is going to walk in.